Attorney AI use
Douglas v. Deutsche Bank National Trust Co.
The court struck an entire appellee brief after counsel used Google’s generative-AI search and cited four nonexistent cases without verification.
Brief struck; disciplinary referral01
Case background
Material facts
Counsel acknowledged using Google’s generative-AI search tool to locate authority and filing the resulting citations without checking them. Four cited cases did not exist: Abadie v. District of Columbia, Cason v. Nat’l Consumer Co-op Bank, Osborne v. District of Columbia, and Woods v. United States. Because the fake cases appeared authentic, the court omitted their full false citations to avoid memorializing them for future AI models to find.
02
The decision
The court’s ruling
The court rejected the firm’s request to preserve the brief with the false citations redacted. It struck the entire appellee brief and referred the matter to disciplinary counsel. The order did not impose a monetary sanction or decide the appeal’s merits.
Why it matters
What the decision means
AI did not sign the brief. Lawyers did. The failure was not the use of an AI search tool; it was filing authorities no one had verified. As the court put it, “A hallucinated citation is, at best, no citation at all; indeed, it is worse.” A basic check would have shown that the four cases did not exist.
Limit of the ruling. The court did not find that AI drafted the brief. A concurrence tied each lawyer’s responsibility to that lawyer’s actual drafting, signing, and supervisory role.
Primary reading