@ai4lawyersTikTok
Attorney AI use

Lisandrillo v. Palozzi

The court referred the matter to the Florida Bar after counsel defended filings containing a false quotation and arguments contradicted by the record. Counsel’s claim of independent verification did not resolve the defects in the filings.

Matter referred to the Florida Bar
01

Case background

Material facts

The court had denied a prohibition petition arising from a dissolution proceeding and ordered counsel to show cause why she should not be sanctioned for frivolous filing. Counsel submitted an 82-page response asserting independent judgment and source verification. She acknowledged that a motion filed below contained a lengthy false quotation attributed to a decision of the same appellate court, but attributed it to human error under time pressure. She also defended a claim that the trial judge mocked her name based on misspellings in an unofficial rough transcript, which contained numerous misspellings of other participants’ names.
02

The decision

The court’s ruling

In its October 21 opinion on the order to show cause, the court referred the matter to the Florida Bar. It found that the response did not deny AI use, evaded the issue, and continued to defend the frivolous arguments addressed in its earlier opinion. The court explained that signing and accepting responsibility for a pleading does not relieve counsel of responsibility for its contents. It rejected counsel’s reliance on obvious transcription errors and identified another assertion contradicted by the transcript: that the judge prevented counsel from moving to disqualify during the hearing.

Why it matters

What the decision means

Review must test the substance of a filing against both the cited authorities and the actual record. A lawyer’s assurance that every word was checked does not cure a false quotation, an unsupported factual claim, or a frivolous argument.
Limit of the ruling. This opinion refers the matter for Bar consideration; it does not impose a disciplinary suspension or decide a Bar proceeding. Counsel attributed the false quotation to human error. The court criticized that explanation but did not identify a particular AI tool as its source. The opinion states that it is not final until disposition of a timely filed rehearing motion.

Primary reading

Sources