@ai4lawyersTikTok
Attorney AI use

State v. Sandoval / In re Stephen D. Aarons

The New Mexico Supreme Court held appellate counsel in direct contempt after a ChatGPT-assisted brief included fabricated witnesses, false testimony, and misrepresented legal authority.

Direct contempt; $5,000 sanction
01

Case background

Material facts

The lawyer represented a defendant appealing a murder conviction. The lawyer admitted that he used ChatGPT to prepare the opening brief and did not verify its factual claims or legal authority before signing and filing it. The brief attributed testimony to four fabricated witnesses, misstated testimony from actual witnesses, and misrepresented two New Mexico decisions. The lawyer also admitted that he did not tell his client about the errors or the court’s show-cause proceedings.
02

The decision

The court’s ruling

The court found the lawyer in direct contempt, ordered him to pay $5,000 to the State Bar of New Mexico Client Protection Fund, referred him to the Disciplinary Board, and barred him from appearing before the court pending that process. It struck all briefing, appointed the Law Office of the Public Defender to represent the defendant, and ordered the appeal to begin again with new briefing. The court concluded that the lawyer had shown “a lack of remorse and a lack of concern for his client.”

Why it matters

What the decision means

Lawyers must verify AI-generated facts as carefully as AI-generated authorities. In an appeal, the record defines what happened. An AI summary cannot substitute for reading that record before signing and filing a brief. The consequences here extended beyond sanctions: the client lost counsel, the briefing was struck, and the appeal had to restart.
Limit of the ruling. The court expressly issued a nonprecedential dispositional order rather than a formal opinion. The order addresses Aarons’s admitted conduct in this appeal and does not establish a general New Mexico rule governing the use of generative AI.

Primary reading

Source