Attorney AI use
Quinteros v. Harbor Distributing, LLC
The California Supreme Court denied review and depublication, leaving in place a published decision affirming sanctions for an AI-assisted brief with fabricated authority.
Review & depublication denied01
Case background
Material facts
In two overlapping California wage-and-hour actions, the defendant moved to stay the later-filed case as overlapping and duplicative. Plaintiff’s counsel assigned the opposition to a contract attorney whom the firm had used for more than a year and whose work it regarded as reliable. The resulting brief contained at least eight fabricated quotations attributed to real California cases, along with serious misstatements of what those cases held. The trial court stressed that fabricated quotations attached to real authorities are especially difficult to detect. Counsel said they used Lexis, Lexis Protégé, and Lexis Citation Check, but no one substantively verified the quotations or holdings against the opinions.
02
The decision
The court’s ruling
The San Francisco Superior Court sanctioned the firm and three lawyers jointly and severally: $5,000 to Harbor and $1,000 to the court, along with notice obligations. The trial judge called the filing “the worst example of misconduct by a lawyer that I think I’ve ever seen since I’ve been on the bench.” The Court of Appeal affirmed on June 11, 2026. On September 2, the California Supreme Court denied the petition for review and the request to depublish the Court of Appeal opinion.
Why it matters
What the decision means
Outsourcing the draft did not transfer counsel of record’s responsibility. Each cited case, quotation, and stated holding had to be checked against the opinion before filing. A citation checker could confirm that a case existed without revealing that the brief had invented what the case said.
Limit of the ruling. The Supreme Court acted without a merits opinion. Its denial left the Court of Appeal opinion published and citable; it did not signify approval of the lower court’s reasoning or create an independent Supreme Court rule on generative AI.
Primary reading